1. I missed the part where I cared about your opinion to let yourself tell me, "For me." Islam is not derived from you or me, but from God and His Messenger. He said His speech is heard, He said He has a voice, and He said He spoke the Qur'an in Arabic.
1/ 13
1/ 13
2. I didn’t realize man existed before God for you to assume that these are exclusively human traits imposed on God, rather than man acquiring his existence and attributes from Him.
3. I never claimed to understand things about my Lord's reality without Him informing me.
3. I never claimed to understand things about my Lord's reality without Him informing me.
So, it’s not my claim about God's speech—it's His revelation about Himself. You need to provide evidence as to why speech is exclusively a human trait. What proof do you have, besides mere speculation, that contradicts clear revelation?
and why should I leave my perfect Lord who can speak and believe in yours that is mute?
4. The reason you're inherently anthropomorphic is because you measure everything God says about Himself by comparing it to creation. If He says He speaks, you immediately
4. The reason you're inherently anthropomorphic is because you measure everything God says about Himself by comparing it to creation. If He says He speaks, you immediately
perceive it as change. What’s the evidence? Again, nonsensical assumptions with zero proof, apart from measuring God against creatures, and having no respect or reverence to him, and his majesty that's beyond conceivability. But arrogance has driven your kind and before them
the Greek pagans to try and investigate the quiddity of God almighty, otherwise he must conform to their euphemistic understanding of the external world that is erroneous in most cases even about mere creatures let alone the mighty creator of all.
5. Yes, you’ve measured your deity against me, assuming He can’t have a hand unless it’s like mine. You're doing it right now when you think that God having a hand, eyes, or a voice automatically equates Him with creation. If you weren’t measuring Him against creation,
you wouldn’t make such assumptions. Otherwise, you should deny His existence, power, knowledge, will, and every other attribute because all of these also exist in creation and are traits of humans and other beings.
6. You can never transcend or go an inch beyond physics
6. You can never transcend or go an inch beyond physics
in understanding your deity. You're confined to physics because it’s the only realm you can conceive of. As a result, you limit God to that realm and measure everything He says about Himself by it. Anything that triggers your anthropomorphic tendencies, you reject
out of ignorance and then you claim transcendence!! How about affirming what He affirms about Himself, as he knows himself better than anyone, without implying any physicality, resemblance or anything you have no knowledge of, especially since he said there is nothing like him?
7. But for you, when He attributes something to Himself, it must be exactly like our attributes, as if you have knowledge of His essence to understand how such an attribute truly exists for Him! I do not understand how you fail to see the sheer audacity in this,
while rejecting everything God said about Himself as problematic and blasphemous, yet you still claim transcendence? As for me, I don’t need to do any of that, because I know that my Lord is far beyond creatures, and everything He said about Himself befits Him
according to His majesty and perfection. That’s what transcendence truly is, and you seem to have no grasp of it. May Allah guide you.
جاري تحميل الاقتراحات...