[1] Could Chapter 19 (Surah Maryam) have been composed after the conquest of the Levant - A thread.
Let aside the fact that it s found in the earliest of Manuscripts, we find nothing, nothing at all, in the Hadith-Athar corpus to support the notion.
Can it be even fathomed...
Let aside the fact that it s found in the earliest of Manuscripts, we find nothing, nothing at all, in the Hadith-Athar corpus to support the notion.
Can it be even fathomed...
[2] that the chapter was added years after the passing of Muhammad and none of the 1000s of companions and Tabi'een even bats an eye?
These are the same people who didn't keep quiet about things which could be considered problematic for the narrative of Quran preservation...
These are the same people who didn't keep quiet about things which could be considered problematic for the narrative of Quran preservation...
They narrated to us:
1) the companion variants which do not conform to the QCT.
2) that Ibn Mas'ud did not believe the in ch. 113 & 114 to be a part of the Quran, and he would erase them from the copies of the Qur'an.
3) that there was a Chrisitian scribe who claimed that...
1) the companion variants which do not conform to the QCT.
2) that Ibn Mas'ud did not believe the in ch. 113 & 114 to be a part of the Quran, and he would erase them from the copies of the Qur'an.
3) that there was a Chrisitian scribe who claimed that...
[4]...he would compose the Qur'an for Muhammad ﷺ [Bukhari: 3617]
4) that there were chapters/ or verses which were recited but are not found in the Quran [e.g. Muslim: 1452]
and then, none of them utters a word about the later composition of this chapter...
4) that there were chapters/ or verses which were recited but are not found in the Quran [e.g. Muslim: 1452]
and then, none of them utters a word about the later composition of this chapter...
[5] or that it was not found in Mushaf of ibn Mas'ud or Ubayy b. Ka'ab for example.
All of them keep mum about it in a collusion of and conspiracy of epic proportions. Rather they start forging narrations about how Ja'far, the cousin of the Prophet, recited this chapter...
All of them keep mum about it in a collusion of and conspiracy of epic proportions. Rather they start forging narrations about how Ja'far, the cousin of the Prophet, recited this chapter...
[6]... in front of Negus, when he and other Muslims migrated to Abyssinia during the Meccan period [Ahmed: 1740]; and about how Abu Hurairah when he first came to Madinah, while the Prophet was out to Khaybar for battle, heard the Prophet's deputized Imam recite this chapter...
[7] while leading the believers in Fajr prayer in the Prophet's Mosque [Ahmed: 8552].
Those who make such claims are more of conspiracy-theorists than being unbiased academics, just like their predecessors mentioned in the Qur'an [Ch. 16]:
[The End]
Those who make such claims are more of conspiracy-theorists than being unbiased academics, just like their predecessors mentioned in the Qur'an [Ch. 16]:
[The End]
![[7] while leading the believers in Fajr prayer in the Prophet's Mosque [Ahmed: 8552].
Those who mak...](https://pbs.twimg.com/media/F2lJ9hSWYAA9m9k.png)
جاري تحميل الاقتراحات...