#BREAKING Supreme Court three judge bench to sit at 9:15 pm tonight to hear appeal filed by rights' activist #TeestaSetalvad , whose regular bail was rejected by Gujarat High Court, earlier today
Earlier 2 judge bench could not agree on a decision
#SupremeCourt
Earlier 2 judge bench could not agree on a decision
#SupremeCourt
A bench of Justices BR Gavai, AS Bopanna and Dipankar Datta to hear the case
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots
Senior Advocate CU Singh and advocate Aparna Bhat appear for Setalvad.
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
Solicitor General Tushar Mehta in court
Senior Adv CU Singh also present
Judges yet to assemble
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
Senior Adv CU Singh also present
Judges yet to assemble
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
Singh: Thank my lords for a Saturday evening hearing.
Justice Gavai: Where is the September 2022 order? (Of the Supreme Court order by then CJI UU Lalit granting interim bail to Setalvad)
Singh takes Court through that order.
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
Justice Gavai: Where is the September 2022 order? (Of the Supreme Court order by then CJI UU Lalit granting interim bail to Setalvad)
Singh takes Court through that order.
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
Singh: The Sessions had been directed to issue directions apart from surrendering passport.
SC: To apply till the HC disposes of regular bail?
Singh: Yes.
SC: what were the conditions?
Singh: Not to interfere etc. Never been called for single interrogation since, not…
SC: To apply till the HC disposes of regular bail?
Singh: Yes.
SC: what were the conditions?
Singh: Not to interfere etc. Never been called for single interrogation since, not…
Singh: Absolutely no case at all of any conditions of bail. 10 months have gone by (since interim bail). Only 2 of 7 sections mentioned in chargesheet non bailable. Only in S 194 and 498.
SC: We are only today concerned by interim protection. When was the impugned order passed?…
SC: We are only today concerned by interim protection. When was the impugned order passed?…
Singh: HC rejected interim stay for 30 days without any reason. Now on merits i only want to say to this extent, on June 24 2022 lordships delivered the judgment in Zakia case.
SC: SIT report was accepted?
Singh: Yes. Said it was keeping pot on boil and action should be…
SC: SIT report was accepted?
Singh: Yes. Said it was keeping pot on boil and action should be…
SG Tushar Mehta: I would expect my lordships to do the same thing that it would do when an ordinary citizen challenges rejection of bail.
Justice Gavai: What is the urgency that a person should not be granted 7 days time to challenge the bail, when she was out for so long. We…
Justice Gavai: What is the urgency that a person should not be granted 7 days time to challenge the bail, when she was out for so long. We…
Justice Gavai: We have seen that for house arrest ... To appeal, a 5 judge bench is constituted to set it aside.
SG: Unfortunate. Here I say it is a question of rule of law, not personal interest. Here she is an ordinary criminal and cannot be subject to special ...but I will…
SG: Unfortunate. Here I say it is a question of rule of law, not personal interest. Here she is an ordinary criminal and cannot be subject to special ...but I will…
SG: SIT constituted by lordships filed periodical reports. Now what happens, it receives witnesses with presigned statements. IO flags this, they say they do not know anything but were given it by the petitioner (Setalvad).
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
SG: On merits in 300-page order her contentions are rejected by HC also. Kindly have a look.
Bench discusses.
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
Bench discusses.
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt #GujaratRiots #bail
SG: Petitioner started collecting money.
Justice Gavai: I had the privilege of reading Bar and Bench before this hearing. They have carried a detailed piece, I had the advantage of reading it. I read during a function only.
#SupremeCourt #TeestaSetalvad
Justice Gavai: I had the privilege of reading Bar and Bench before this hearing. They have carried a detailed piece, I had the advantage of reading it. I read during a function only.
#SupremeCourt #TeestaSetalvad
SG continues: Entire State was maligned. Entire machinery... Not a question of one individual.
SC: Question is anything .. whether heavens will fall in 7 days?
SG: Heavens never fall.
Justice Datta says if keeping her behind bars was intention, earlier bench would not give…
SC: Question is anything .. whether heavens will fall in 7 days?
SG: Heavens never fall.
Justice Datta says if keeping her behind bars was intention, earlier bench would not give…
Justice Gavai: We are only on whether single judge was right on not giving interim stay
Justice Datta: With the judgment coming on a Saturday when it comes to loss of liberty. Two judges also had a difference of opinion.
SG: what can I do?
Justice Datta: Not the point. You…
Justice Datta: With the judgment coming on a Saturday when it comes to loss of liberty. Two judges also had a difference of opinion.
SG: what can I do?
Justice Datta: Not the point. You…
#Breaking
Justice Gavai remarks: We find that learned single judge was totally wrong in not giving interim stay ... When she was out for 7 months.
SG: She had done some shocking ...
#SupremeCourt #TeestaSetalvad
Justice Gavai remarks: We find that learned single judge was totally wrong in not giving interim stay ... When she was out for 7 months.
SG: She had done some shocking ...
#SupremeCourt #TeestaSetalvad
Justice Bopanna: We are ready to pass orders saying Good Morning also (smiles).
Justice Gavai: Appearing for the mighty State Mr SG.
#SupremeCourt #TeestaSetalvad
Justice Gavai: Appearing for the mighty State Mr SG.
#SupremeCourt #TeestaSetalvad
SG: Somebody takes Institutions for a joy ride. She writes to Geneva. State maligned.
Justice Datta: Mr Solicitor, her conduct may be reprehensible, but to deny her interim liberty even for a day?
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt
Justice Datta: Mr Solicitor, her conduct may be reprehensible, but to deny her interim liberty even for a day?
#TeestaSetalvad #SupremeCourt
SG takes Court through earlier HC orders against Setalvad.
Singh: It was stayed.
SG: No. Designer shoes were purchased.
Justice Gavai: We are repeating, what will happen if she is given 7 days to challenge? We will direct it to be listed before regular bench and we will…
Singh: It was stayed.
SG: No. Designer shoes were purchased.
Justice Gavai: We are repeating, what will happen if she is given 7 days to challenge? We will direct it to be listed before regular bench and we will…
Order: Two judges differed whether Petitioner was to be given interim protection or not. Then the CJI constituted the present bench of us three judges.
SG: If lordships can not observe ...
Justice Gavai: We are not. I had said elaborate discussions to be avoided in bail.…
SG: If lordships can not observe ...
Justice Gavai: We are not. I had said elaborate discussions to be avoided in bail.…
SG: Lordships may only extend time to surrender. If stay it will never be heard.
SC: We will take care of that.
Order: SLP filed against rejection of regular bail. We are not on merits but only going through that part of order asking for immediate surrender. In ordinary…
SC: We will take care of that.
Order: SLP filed against rejection of regular bail. We are not on merits but only going through that part of order asking for immediate surrender. In ordinary…
Order: One of the contentions then was that the petitioner is a lady.
SG: This will affect in final ...
Justice Gavai: Mr Solicitor ...
Order: We find that taking into consideration this fact, ld single judge ought to have granted some time to Petitioner to challenge the…
SG: This will affect in final ...
Justice Gavai: Mr Solicitor ...
Order: We find that taking into consideration this fact, ld single judge ought to have granted some time to Petitioner to challenge the…
جاري تحميل الاقتراحات...